The Limitations of Cyber Risk Assessment Tools
Several months ago, I was asked by an executive, “ how much should we be spending on cyber insurance?" . A reasonable question – one which had me searching for a tool that could help me both frame and answer the question. I decided to reach out to my network for suggestions, and several people pointed me to the FAIR Framework. This felt like a reasonable fit, I was familiar with FAIR and had used it in the past. However, after persisting with FAIR for several days, it soon became clear that FAIR wasn’t the right tool for the job. Not all cyber risk tools are fit for the job. In this second instalment (Part 1 here), I share my thoughts on cyber risk tooling and examine situations in which certain cyber tools are preferable, and situations in which they are not. CYBER RISK ANALYSIS I wanted to start this discussion by briefly discussing cyber risk analysis. In Part 1, I showed that the typical cyber risk management process looks something like this: Identify risks Analyse risks usin